November 19, 2026
Bunny's Cottage sits close to the Sky Pool, the Rosemary Beach Fitness Center and the Racquet Club. The beach is about 500 steps away through Walkover C near the Eastern Green. On the town's own rental site, this one property has three listings. Bunny's Cottage is the main house, with five bedrooms and room for 10. Bunny's Carriage House has two bedrooms, two baths and room for four. Bunny's Cottage & Carriage House is both together: seven bedrooms, 6.5 baths, 14 guests and 3,020 square feet.
Each of the three listings has its own advertised rate, and the combined booking is priced below the two units listed separately. The carriage house is marketed as a product of its own, for a smaller guest than the one the main house is built for.
The advertised starting rates are $825 a day for the cottage and $329 a day for the carriage house. The combined booking starts at $1,072 a day. Book the two units separately and you pay $1,154 a day. Book them together and the price drops by $82, about 7 percent.
The combined listing puts a group of 14 under one booking, and the operator prices that bundle below the two separate rates. On these listed rates, the carriage house commands its full $329 starting price when a separate party of up to four books it.
Treat these as listing prices, not results. They are undated "from" rates shown on the rental pages. They aren't quotes for the same dates, and they don't show occupancy, gross receipts or net income. What they do show is how a manager who rents both products in this town decided to price them against each other.
The separate pricing makes more sense once you know the carriage house wasn't added later. According to the Rosemary Beach Property Owners Association's architecture page, Andres Duany and Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk of DPZ drew the first Rosemary Beach Town Plan in 1995, 15 years after they planned Seaside. Their goal was to keep Seaside's fundamentals and add features that would give Rosemary Beach its own identity.
Cars were the first of those features. The same page says the planners brought cars into town with "an alley system and carriage house addition which provided living space, a rental opportunity and of course, hidden parking." Moving garages to the alleys let front doors face boardwalks, paths and lawns instead of streets. The town plan sorts every parcel into twelve basic lot types, and different architects designed the individual homes under one shared set of guidelines. Today those guidelines sit inside the POA's Code, which covers regulating, urban, architectural and landscaping standards and how design review works, as laid out on its First Principles page.
So the rental opportunity is written into the town's founding plan, next to parking. When a Rosemary Beach owner lists a carriage house as its own rental, they are using the unit the way the plan described it.
The guest a carriage house attracts is different from the group that fills the main house. All Seasons 30A, which manages homes only in Rosemary Beach, groups its carriage houses into a collection of seven listings. Six of them show the pattern clearly.
| Listing | Bedrooms | Sleeps | Advertised starting rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 56 Johnstown | 1, studio | 2 | $175/night |
| 207 Wiggle Lane | 1 | 2 | $195/night |
| 68 Johnstown | 2 | 4 | $225/night |
| 23 S Cartagena | 1 | 2 | $250/night |
| 188 Round | 1 | 2 | $295/night |
| 53 N Cartagena | 2 | 4 | $295/night |
Four of the six sleep two people. The descriptions target couples directly. 188 Round is described as a pied-à-terre about a minute's walk from the beach, 23 S Cartagena is pitched to couples with Gulf views from its veranda, and 53 N Cartagena is pitched as a romantic getaway for two. 56 Johnstown belongs to the company's Always Collection of adults-only carriage homes, which greets guests with champagne and designer robes. Even the larger units are small. 68 Johnstown, called the Francois Carriage House, is 750 square feet with a wraparound balcony and one parking space. Carolina Carriage House, listed by the Rosemary Beach Cottage Rental Company, is 464 square feet.
A family of ten booking a five-bedroom cottage is a different customer from a couple booking a studio for a long weekend. Neither competes with the other for the same nights. A lot with both buildings can sell to both customers, and at Bunny's that separate listing is where the carriage house carries its full advertised rate.
The rates for these small units also stay within a narrow band. Bunny's two-bedroom carriage house starts at $329 a day. All Seasons' six listings run from $175 to $295 a night, depending on size, finishes and distance to the beach.
Winter gives the carriage house one more kind of guest. On the Rosemary Beach Cottage Rental Company's winter rentals page, named carriage houses such as Rosemary's Pineapple Carriage House and Almost Heaven Carriage House appear in the seasonal inventory, and the company says its properties can be booked for anything from a week to the whole winter. On Tucker's Lane, the Sunsets at Rosemary Carriage House is marketed with low monthly winter rates. Its snowbird season runs November through February, monthly stays start and end on the first of the month, and a monthly booking carries a $150 cleaning fee.
That snowbird season is already underway on publish day. A monthly winter stay is one more way a small unit is marketed apart from the house in front of it, with one arrival on the first of the month and a single cleaning fee.
If the carriage house really is a separate product, judge it as one. The main house's rental history won't tell you what the unit on the alley can do. A few questions show it more clearly:
All of the rates in this post are advertised starting prices taken from public rental pages. They are not earnings projections. This post is general information, not financial or tax advice, so confirm any income assumptions for a specific property with your own advisors.
For more on the town, see our guide to choosing a rental program for a Rosemary Beach home and the Rosemary Beach neighborhood page.
If you're weighing a Rosemary Beach home with a carriage house, or deciding how to rent the one you already own, Bellville Team can walk you through both sides. Brad and Kimberly represent the purchase, and through Coastal Blue Vacations they can help you decide whether the unit on the alley should rent with the house, rent by itself, or stay open for family. Start Your Coastal Journey with a conversation about the lot you have in mind.
Experience a level of service that goes beyond transactions. Whether you’re buying, selling, or exploring short-term rentals, we’re here to offer personalized insights and exclusive local expertise. Let’s collaborate to unlock your dream lifestyle on Santa Rosa Beach—because every connection brings you one step closer to the home you deserve.